Friday, October 04, 2013

Call for Papers for the Upcoming EUR Research Seminar on Austerity, Health and Human Rights

On Friday, November 22, 2013 the Erasmus University Rotterdam (EUR) will conduct a research seminar on austerity, health and human rights.

 “Austerity is devastating for the world’s poorest” stated Magdalena SepĂșlveda of the UN reporting on extreme poverty. Various UN human rights organizations have voiced the same sentiment.

National experience regarding health care illustrates just how dire the situation has become. The hardships of austerity can be seen in countries such as Greece that had to depend on bailouts. Especially health professionals are concerned since cuts in financing harm the needy.

In contrast to the standpoint of the UN, various NGOs and concerned professionals, governments and international financial institutions point out that austerity is necessary given the current economic climate.

Some academics disagree. Robert Unger wonders if cuts in healthcare are really necessary in order to restart the economy, or if politicians use it as a convenient way to shift cuts those that don’t have the (political) cloud to retaliate.

SusanMarks feels that cuts in healthcare leads to infringement on human rights. She labels those cuts as neo-liberal economic policies that promote those cuts as the best way to solve economic issues.

Both scholars want to “politicize” and “radicalize” the human rights discourse and practices. They feel that the “liberal neutrality of other mainstays of the human rights movement” is counterproductive. This raises an interesting question: How should the human rights community respond to the current economic crisis?

The Erasmus University Rotterdam invites you to submit one or more papers addressing the questions outlined below. Papers should discuss the right to health in a holistic framework and include social parameters such as food, housing, energy and fuel:
  • Are austerity measures necessary?
  • What systemic or structural reasons or causes underlie the emergence of current austerity measures?
  • Who benefits from austerity measures?
  • Are there alternatives to austerity and what might those be?
  • Beyond austerity can we envision another way based on human rights?

Academic researchers and practitioners are invited to address these questions from a human rights perspective. The seminar welcomes interdisciplinary scholarship.  Interested participants are invited to submit a one-page abstract that outlines their paper. In addition, a selected bibliography can be attached in a single page.

Successful participants will be given 20 minutes to present and 10 minutes for comments and questions. Publication of the seminar papers may be considered. All abstracts will go through a peer review process.

Interested participants can submit their abstracts to Mr Toby Hollen at: info@erasmusobservatoryonhealthlaw.nl not later than Friday October 11, 2013

Saturday, September 21, 2013

Brian Holloway (a linebacker and gentleman) vs. 300 spoiled brads on a crime spree (and their delusional parents)

During the LaborDay weekend of 2013, 300 high school kids decided to have fun and broke into the $1.5
million home of former All-Pro NFL lineman Brian Holloway. They not only trashed his Stephentown, NY vacation home, but proudly tweeted about their step-by-step drinking, drug using and destruction spree.

The result of their “handiwork”?
  • Around $20,000 in damages
  • Scars on the floor from where they dragged keggers into the mansion
  • Ruined carpets soaked with beer, liquor and other beverages
  • Punched walls
  • Graffiti on wooden walls
  • 10 bags of empty liquor bottles, 50 empty bottles of liquor and drug paraphernalia
Amazingly enough, Mr. Holloway was extremely gracious about the episode. Being a father himself, he showed concern for these out-of-control brads and wanted to help.
He stated: “Everything broken can be fixed, everything that was stolen can be replaced, but 300 lives are in trouble. The most important thing is to save these kids lives.”

He appealed to the adolescent-delinquents-in-training (my phrasing, not his) to come forward and make amends by helping to clean up and help with a benefit for veterans. He also set up a website www.helpmesave300.com where almost all of the photos and tweets have been uploaded from the Labor Day weekend destruction spree (Chapeau for social media and the vanitas vanitatis of adolescent narcissists!)

On this site, Holloway wrote: "Come out and help set up, fix up, bring food, and picnic stuff, so we can honor these real HEROS. I'm here. Come now. Take a stand for your future. This is called redemption."

The response: only one (1) showed up! (I applaud this kid and his/her parents). It however painfully illustrates that a staggering 299 spoiled brads and their dysfunctional parent units just did not give a damn. Even worse: some of those parents are angry about the web site and the posted photos of their little darlings. They even threatened to sue Holloway.

His baffled response: "Your kids are in my house breaking and stealing my stuff and you are mad at me because I posted pictures that they took and posted themselves of them partying and tearing things up?"

Note to the patents of @nicky_roden23, @mhart7, @_cwarren2546, @DFresh518, @@RickNels, @Alwiha_Skaarup, @BigTone5621, @ricky_roden23 – please wake up and smell the coffee. Your kid is on a slippery slope to deviant behavior/crime (that cannot be justified as a “youthful indiscretion”). Your offspring is exposed now and will be searchable for years to come on the World Wide Web. The tweets and pics (posted by your brads themselves with the smartphones you pay for!) will impact their admission to a decent college/university as well as any job application since it shows that they committed a criminal act. So success with that! As the parent unit of an out-of-control kid – please make amends. It’s the least you and your kids can do.
Some gems posted by the little thugs (for future reference and general amusement): 



Thursday, September 19, 2013

Guatemala Is Cracking Down On Cell Phone Thieves

In most countries, stealing a cell phone is prosecuted as petty theft. In Guatemala, this kind of theft has grown into a “national emergency”.  Cell phone theft is often violent, resulting in grave bodily harm and even death.
Guatemala is a country with around 15 million residents and a phone theft of 12,000 everymonth. According to the Superintendency of Telecommunications, a staggering 142,745 cell phones were stolen in 2012, representing an increase of 40% compared to the previous year 2011. It means that every 4 minutes, a person is robbed of his/her cell phone.
Guatemala decided to tackle the problem. Recently, the Congress passed a law making cell phone theft punishable with stiff prison sentences of up to 15 years and fines up to $ 31,250). Furthermore, the passed law also creates a national register of devices used in the country.
According to the new law, cell phone theft:
  • Carries penalties of between 5 to 10 years in prison for thieves- without possibility of parole
  • Carries fines of 40,000 to 100,000 quetzals ($5,000 to $12,500) for people who purchase phones from questionable sources
  • Carries prison sentences of 6 to 10 years for persons selling cell phones illegally
  • Carries fines of 100,000 to 250,000 quetzals ($12,500 and $31,250) for individuals selling phones illegally
Furthermore, the use of cell phones in prison, by inmates or employees will also be punishable under the new law.

We can only applaud Guatemala on its initiative!
(Image: Courtesy of Corporate Travel Safety)

Monday, July 29, 2013

Dutch Radboud University Demands The Right To Publish Research On Hacking Security Codes Of Luxury Cars

Scientific researchers Baris Ege and Roel Verdult are two researchers at the Radboud University in Nijmegen, the Netherlands. Together with FlavioD. Garcia, a colleague at the University of Birmingham, they conducted research on how secret codes of luxury cars can be hacked.

In their article “Dismantling Megamos Crypto”, they describe in detail how the security method Megamos Crypto can be hacked. Megamos Crypto is used in luxury brands such as Volkswagen, Bugatti and Bentley.

The research was slated to be published and presented in August 2013 at the USENIX security symposium in Washington. The Volkswagen Group requested that the researchers would publish their article without describing the exact code. The three scientists refused “out of principle” claiming that the general public has a right to know about security holes and flaws in car security systems.

The Volkswagen Group went to court, arguing that publication of the article would “facilitate” gangs specializing in luxury car theft. The judge agreed and issued an injunction, stating that the article could lead to theft of millions of cars such as Porsches, Audis, and Lamborghinis.

The Radboud University expressed its disappointment since “the injunction does not comply with freedom of academic publishing”. The university also pointed out that to steal a car, cracking the security code is not enough. “Our researchers found out how the immobilizer can be turned off. However, the thief must also get into the car to disengage the car alarm.”

The universities will fight for their right to publish in court at a later date.

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

Pippa Middleton Takes Legal Action Against @PippaTips The Streisand Effect

Mat Morrisroe and Suzanne Azzopardi started tweeting as @PippaTips. Their hilarious tweets spoofed Pippa’s predictable party tips.

Some gems include;
@PippaTip: avoid awkward silences by talking
@PippaTip: when driving at night lights aren't only a legal requirement, but a fun way of seeing the road and other things
@PippaTip: if you're shopping on a budget, try purchasing things that cost less to buy
@PippaTip: breakfast is a yummy way to get rid of hunger after waking. Toast (re-cooked bread), cereal or eggs with bacon are always winners
@PippaTip: the weekend is a good opportunity to do things you don't have time to during the week
@PippaTip: headache tablets can be a great in helping deal with a headache
@PippaTip: form friendships by being nice to people you like
@PippaTip: a refreshing afternoon nap can be enjoyed by taking a nap in the afternoon
With more than 50,000 Twitter followers, the dynamic duo launched "When One is Expecting: APosh Person's Guide to Pregnancy and Parenting". It’s a parody of Pippa’s quiteunsuccessful book Celebrate.

Ms. Middleton was not amused and instructed her lawyers Harbottle &Lewis LLP to demand that the @PippaTips Twitter account must be deleted

Part of Pippa’s chagrin could be the fact that the spoof is outselling the original on Amazon. Celebrate ranks at #3,370, while the @PippaTips book ranks at #961.


Sales in bookshops are still better for Celebrate. Pippa did not do herself a favor with her public outcry. It generated a lot of publicity that only helps to boost sales for @PippaTips. It’s a classic example of the Streisand Effect.

Wednesday, July 03, 2013

Fatal Attraction – Economist Heleen Mees Arrested in New York For Stalking Former Lover

Dutch economist Heleen Mees has been arrested in New York for stalking, harassing and aggravated harassing Willem Buiter. Her court date is May 5th. 

She was released after posting bail set at $5,000.--.
Furthermore, Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Robert Mandelbaum issued Mees an order of protection and demanded she stay away from Buiter and his family.

“Do not call them, do not go to their home, school, businesses, place of employment . . . no email, no text messages, instant messages, no phone calls, letters, fax or voice messages,” the judge said.

Ms. Mees apparently sent more than 1,000 emails over two years to Mr. Buiter, a chief economist at Citigroup. The two had an affair. Ms. Mees was crazy about Buiters. But once the romance went sour, Mees went into fatal attraction-mode, sending racy, to X-rated, to demented emails. Threatening emails were not only sent to Buiter himself, but also to his wife Anne and children. She even continued to contact him after receiving a cease-and-desist letter.

According to the filed court papers, emails included:

“What can I do to make it right? Shall I lick your b---s?”
“Shall we adopt a child?”
“Hope your plane falls out of the sky.”

In addition to sending him X-rated images of herself, she sent him a photo of dead birds. Go figure.

Heleen Mees currently lives in NYC and was previously lecturing at the Dutch Universities Universityof Tilburg and the Eramus University Rotterdam (EUR). She also served as the Adjunct Associate Professor in Economics at Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service. 

Ironically, she is known for her feminism, being a co-founder of “Women on Top”. She also wrote for the prestigious Dutch financial newspaper FD. 

Thursday, June 06, 2013

German Court Rules: Autocomplete of Google Searches Can Be Illegal


The founder of a public company sued Google (NASDAQ:GOOG) since googling the name of his company offered autocomplete searches that connected the company’s name with "Scientology" and "Fraud". According to the plaintiff, these autocompletes were baseless. Furthermore, they infringe on personal rights as well as corporate image.

The GermanFederal Court of Justice agreed and ruled that Google’s autocomplete function sometimes present suggestions that are considered to be a breach of law. With this ruling, the court overturned the verdict of the District Court of Cologne.

The ruling could help former First Lady Bettina Wulff with her lawsuit against Google. When her name is googled, Google’s autocomplete function offers additions such as "red light district" and "escort." Needless to say, the lady is not amused.
 
The ruling does not imply that Google is liable for each and every autocomplete. Owners of search engines “Are not obligated to check the legality of autocomplete searched proactively for liability”. Only when a victim reports infringement must the search engine owner take action.

Google spokesperson Kay Oberbeck explained that the autocomplete suggestions are generated by users searching Google, not by Google itself.

According to German lawyers, Google’s autocomplete function could go two ways: (1) the autocomplete function will be completely deactivated in Germany, or (2) users will be automatically able to remove autocomplete suggestions.

One thing is clear, Google has to react quickly!

Saturday, May 25, 2013

German Fashion Designer Philipp Plein is Taking (Legal) Action Against Robert Geiss for IP Infringement


Robert and Michael Geiss founded “Uncle Sam”, a sports apparel label in 1986 and sold it in January 1995 for a reported 140M. DM.

Robert Geiss and his family have a reality show on German TV “The Geisses – a terribly glamorous family”. The family resides in tax haven Monaco ("A sunny place for shady people").

At the beginning of March 2013, Robert Geiss launched his new fashion label "Roberto Geissini". According to fashion designer Philipp Plein, Geiss ripped off his designs – especially his trademark skulls, ornate lettering, and bling-bling.

In contrast to Geiss, Plein is a well-established fashion designer. His "heavy metal" collection featured on "Germany's Next Top Model" presented by Heidi Klum. At the Nuremburg Toy Fair 2009, he collaborated with Mattel (NASDAQ:MAT) in creating the Philipp Plein Barbie doll to celebrate 50 years of Barbies. 

Plein has stores in Monte Carlo, Milan, Vienna, Moscow, St. Tropez, Cannes, KitzbĂŒhel, DĂŒsseldorf, Forte dei Marmi, Hong Kong, Marbella, Baku, Dubai, St. Petersburg, Seoul, Macau, Amsterdam and Berlin. Plein also dresses the team players of A.S.Roma.

The Roberto Geissini fashion like also feature skulls, ornate lettering, and bling-bling. It raises the strong suspicion that Geiss is a copycat.

Needless to say, Philipp Plein is checking his legal options, stating that “we take action on each instance of counterfeiting.” He explained to the Berlin newspaper “BZ” that the house style is “unique” and that “people buy Philipp Plein for its brand, not just as a product.”

In the end the court will have to decide if bling-bling skulls can be seen as IP. As it looks now, Geiss is for sure guilty of piggy-back riding – and may be of infringement of IP.

Saturday, May 18, 2013

IP Rights Take Precedent over Nature – Courtesy of the US Supreme Court

Mr. Bowman, a 74-year-old soybean farmer, bought soybean seed from a local grain elevator that was contaminated with the patented seed. He used those seeds in good faith to produce soy beans on his 299 acres of farmland.

Bowman began purchasing Monsanto’s patented seeds in 1999 and, because of the licensing agreement, did not save any of the seed for future planting. But he also bought so-called “commodity” seed from a local grain elevator, which acts as a clearinghouse for farmers to buy and sell seed.

The elevator’s seed was contaminated with Monsanto’s patented seed since more than 90 percent of the soybeans planted in the area were Roundup Ready crops. Mr. Bowman planted that commodity seed which was substantially cheaper to purchase. He produced a second, late-season crop, which is generally more risky and has lower yield.

He also used seeds generated in one late-season harvest to help produce subsequent late-season crops.

According to Monsanto, the farmer should have known that the seed was Monsanto’s IP since the seeds were resistant to herbicides.

Monsanto promptly sued the farmer for patent infringement which case Mr. Bowman (quite correctly) won. The farmer’s lawyer argued that “this issue affects every farmer in the country and the method of planting that farmers such as Mr. Bowman have used for generations.”

Monsanto appealed to the Supreme Court to get its pound of flesh. Mr. Bowman argued that the Supreme Court should analyze whether the law allows patent holders to “continue to assert patent rights after an authorized sale.”

The case therefore centered on the question how far down the stream of commerce (e.g., the farming cycle) is a company such as Monsanto allowed to enforce its patents. This is even more poignant since soybeans can easily self-replicate.

A lower court, an appeals court, the Barack Obama administration and the Supreme Court all claim that the stream is virtually endless.

The US Supreme Court has for the first time backed patents for a self-replicating technology. It ruled in favor of Monsanto’s “Roundup Ready” soybeans, along with its licensing agreement that allows farmers to use them only once.

This licensing agreement with forbids farmers to resell the seeds for commercial planting, and those seeds can also not be used for research, crop breeding or seed production.

The ruling is a clear sign of how patented, genetically modified organisms get legitimacy. The Supreme Court ruling was unanimous. It ruled IP rights take precedent over nature – go figure!

In this case, the court ruled against an Indiana soybean farmer. A lower court ruled in favor of the Monsanto and ordered the farmer to pay $84,456 in damages and costs to Monsanto in 2009 for infringing its soybean patents.

Justice Elena Kagan explained: “If simple copying were a protected use, a patent would plummet in value after the first sale of the first item containing the invention. The undiluted patent monopoly, it might be said, would extend not for 20 years as the Patent Act promises, but for only one transaction. And that would result in less incentive for innovation than Congress wanted.”

According to Kagan, “were the matter otherwise, Monsanto’s patent would provide scant benefit.” As a fellow lawyer, I can only say: So what? Not every patent is enforceable, let alone profitable!

The Obama administration instructed the Supreme Court that its justices should not concern themselves with the eventuality that such rigid patent protectionism could undermine traditional farming techniques. The administration went on to point out that Congress “is better equipped than this court” to handle these issues. Is the government not blatantly interfering with the justice system? A slippery slope indeed!

Monsanto informed the Supreme Court that if it would rule in favor of the soybean farmer, it would doom its business model.

In my lawyer’s opinion, this decision is bad, really bad. Farmers who buy seed in good faith should be able to use them to use them to produce food for all of us. Monsanto might have scored a commercial victory, but on the marketing and PR front – the company lost big time!

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Harper Lee Sues Her Agent Samuel Pinkus Over ‘Mockingbird’ Royalties

For those of you who don’t know - Harper Lee is the author of one of my favorites – “To Kill a Mockingbird” which was published in 1960. The novel is set in the racial South and won a Pulitzer Prize. It was also turned into a compelling movie featuring the legendary actor Gregory Peck who won an Oscar for his portrayal of lawyer Atticus Finch.

Harper Lee is still alive, at the ripe age of 87. Ms. Lee has failing eyesight and hearing. She resides in an assisted-living facility since 2007 after suffering a stroke.

Harper Lee engages McIntoshand Otis as her literary agent for many years. When Eugene Winick,one of the principles at the firm became ill in 2002, his son-in-law Mr. Samuel Pinkus took over. Pinkus was sued by McIntosh for stealing several clients, including Ms. Lee.

In 2007, Ms. Lee signed a document assigning her copyright to her agent’s company. The idea was that her agent, Mr. Samuel Pinkus, would act on her behalf.

Once Harper Lee found out that her agent took advantage of her advanced age and infirmity to swindle her out of royalties due to her. She promptly sued at the federal court in New York. ( Lee v. Pinkus, 13-3000, U.S. District Court, U.S. Bankruptcy Court,Southern District of New York (Manhattan).

Samuel Pinkus et al are sued to confirm Harper Lee’s copyright ownership of “To Kill a Mockingbird”.  In her suit, she asks that all commissions received by Pinkus will be forfeited.

Last year, Lee’s copyright was re-assigned to her after legal action. Samuel Pinkus was fired as her agent. However, he kept receiving royalties from sales of “To Kill a Mockingbird” as detailed  in the legal complaint.

According to Harper Lee’s lawyer Ms. Gloria Phares: “Pinkus knew that Harper Lee was an elderly woman with physical infirmities that made it difficult for her to read and see.  Harper Lee had no idea she had assigned her copyright.”

The defendants, Samuel Pinkus and his wife Ann Winick did not respond. Ms. Winick is the president of Keystone Literary LLC and listed as a defendant. Another named defendant, Gerald Posner, also did not respond. Mr. Posner is a New York lawyer and investigative journalist who incorporated one of Pinkus’s businesses.

Ms. Lee wrote an amazing novel that inspired generations. Taking advantage of her is just obnoxious. Let’s hope that the court sees it the same way.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

France: Recourse for Deformation on Facebook Will Only Succeed in Case of Many Friends


According to the French Supreme Court, insults posted on social networks are not statements made in public. The insulted party can therefore not sue for defamation of character or public insult. 

The case involved employees who posted insulting texts about their employer on Facebook. They were fired and a lower court upheld the dismissal arguing that the employees had publicly insulted their ex-employer.

The Supreme Court overturned the verdict, arguing that the texts of the employees were only visible for friends. It was therefore part of private communications. It reasoned that the statements could only be accessed by persons that were authorized by the account holder, and therefore not be read by the general public.

The verdict does not clarify what exactly the difference between private and public communication is. Statements made on a Facebook-page that can be accessed by the general public, can still be considered to be private if the account holder has a “small circle” of friends.

The employees in question celebrated the verdict. The penalty for public insults can reach Euro 12,000 per incident under French law, while a non-public insult carries a fine of maximum Euro 38. Racist insults made in public are punishable with a fine of up to Euro 45,000 plus prison time.

In France, it will be harder for employers to fired employees that post derogatory statements or insults about them on their Facebook-pages.

(Image courtesy of Tigerlily Flatform)

Monday, April 01, 2013

Germany’s Academic and Political Plagiarism Epidemic


Today Iderminister_-_h_2013 watched (and thoroughly enjoyed) the German movie “Der Minister”. It is a wonderful satire of the Guttenberg plagiarism scandal.

As it turns out, this clever satire is itself a work of plagiarism. Several great lines seem to be taken from TV series such as the iconic British “Yes Minister” series – more specifically:  “It used to be said there were two kinds of chairs to go with two kinds of Minister: one sort folds up instantly; the other sort goes round and round in circles.”

The screenwriter Dorothee Schon justified it by stating that content was taken from the media collage surrounding Guttenberg. An interesting legal argument indeed!

To refresh your memory, Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg was a charismatic German politician who served as the Minister of Defense under Angela Merkel. Guttenberg received his doctorate from the University of Bayreuth (founded in 1975 and located in Bavaria, Germany) in the year 2007. After it was found that he had plagiarized parts of his doctoral dissertation, the university revoked is doctorate. Once he was caught, Guttenberg left German politics all together in 2011. He reinvented himself in the US.

Being an academic is a big deal in Germany. It helps with getting well-paid jobs and has substantial social standing. According to a  survey conducted by the German newspaper “Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung”  18.5 % of MPs in the German Bundestag carry doctor or professor titles. It is obviously a big plus for becoming a Minister! According to law professor Prof. Dr.Volker Rieble of the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, Germans suffer from “title arousal.” He points out that people in other countries are not as vain about their titles. (Israel is a good example – most people in middle and higher management have two academic degrees and seldom mention them). This obsession with academic titles obviously sparks the tendency to take short cuts to obtain the prized Dr. title.

As it turned out, the Guttenberg affair was not an isolated incident (as I originally thought). Following the Guttenberg debacle, several other German politicians were also caught in the act, including Prof. Dr. AnnetteSchavan who (ironically) served as the Minister of Education. Way back in 1980, she wrote a dissertation of a whopping 351 pages that had been gathering dust in the archives of the Heinrich Heine University in DĂŒsseldorf until an anonymous blogger (SchavanPlag on WordPress) published a long list of sections that were ripped off other works. The University of DĂŒsseldorf promptly stripped her of her Dr. title. She subsequently resigned her post in February 2013.

The German website “VroniPlag” is a living nightmare for German politicians that got their academic degree in a questionable way. The website states that: “VroniPlag Wiki is a scientific project without any political or commercial interests”. They obviously do a lot of due diligence.  Cave Doctor (Latin for: Dr. be aware)!

Other disgraced German politicians include:
  • Silvana Koch-Mehrin, former vice president of the European Parliament and member of the German Free Democratic Party, was stripped of her doctorate in 2011 by the University of Heidelberg;
  • Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, a German member of the European Parliament, was stripped of his Ph. D. by the University of Bonn in 2011;
  • Florian Graf, another German politician, lost his Ph. D. once he confessed that he had lifted parts of other works without permission for his dissertation.
Will this be the end of it? Lean back and wait!
By the way, Angie aka Angela Merkel is officially Dr. Merkel since she holds a doctorate from the University of Leipzig.

Saturday, March 30, 2013

A New York Court Ruled that Clipping Content from Internet without Payment is not Covered by Fair Use


Meltwater is a Norwegian clipping service that monitors news about its clients on the Web. These paying clients include companies and governments that fork out good money to outsource trolling the internet for news items themselves. Meltwater provides them with news alerts, newsletters and access to a searchable database.

Those newsletters include introductory sections of news stories (aka “ledes”) that were taken from the Associated Press (AP) and other sources. AP promptly demanded that Meltwater buy a license to distribute news story excerpts. Meltwater refused, pointing out that lifting those ledes from the internet is covered by the fair use rules. AP then sued Meltwater for copyright infringement.

In court, Meltwater argued its activities are identical to those of search engines such as Google (which is showing headlines and text snippets in search results and is covered by the fair use rules. Meltwater would therefore be allowed to clip and display news stories that were found on internet.

U.S. District Judge Denise Cote disagreed and ruled that there are limits to the amount of content an internet scraping service such as Meltwater can lift from internet without payment stating: “Instead of driving subscribers to third-party websites, Meltwater News acts as a substitute for news sites operated or licensed by AP.”

This ruling is also based on the “click-through” rate of the news stories that Meltwater dissipated. According the judge, Meltwater had lifted more than was necessary for a search engine and that is therefore harmed AP stating: “Paraphrasing James Madison, the world is indebted to the press for triumphs which have been gained by reason and humanity over error and oppression [...] Permitting Meltwater to take the fruit of AP’s labor for its own profit, without compensating AP, injures AP’s ability to perform this essential function of democracy.”

Reactions to the ruling were mixed. According to Techdirt’s Mike Masnick, the judge misinterpreted the “fair use” rules, while AP and the New York Times were happy.

Needless to say, Meltwater appealed - so stay tuned!

Thursday, March 28, 2013

To Be Googleable or Ungoogleable – That’s the Question in the State of Sweden


Some brand names and trademarks have become generic words. “Hoovering" (brand name Hoover) in the UK is the generic word for vacuum cleaning. Aspirin (trademark of Bayer) has become a generic term to refer to any OTC painkiller.

Google is facing a similar dilemma. “To Google” nowadays refers to searching the internet – regardless of the search engine used. (I often joke that Descartes would have stated: “I can be googled, therefore I exist”)

Google addressed this threat its brand name in its IPO filing. Under the intellectual property heading of the risks section it said: “We also face risks associated with our trademarks. For example, there is a risk that the word “Google” could become so commonly used that it becomes synonymous with the word “search.” If this happens, we could lose protection for this trademark, which could result in other people using the word “Google” to refer to their own products, thus diminishing our brand.”

Google is therefore keeping track of the dangers of its brand name becoming generic. That’s why they objected to the Swedish term “ogooglebar” (“something that you can't find on the web with the use of a search engine”). Google demanded that the Language Council of Sweden would change the term to “something you can’t find on the web with the use of Google search”.

The Language Council of Sweden refused and decided to drop the term "ungoogleable" from its list of new words. According to the Council’s spokesperson Ann Cederberg, “engaging Google's lawyers took too much time and resources." According to her, the Council therefore opted to remove the phrase from its 2012 list of new words. She furthermore stated that "ungoogleable" is already a popular word in Sweden.  Google will therefore have a uphill battle to stop Swedes from using it.

For Google, it’s a Catch-22 for Google. They are on one hand the most popular brand associated with web searching. But on the other hand, Google want to protect its brand to prevent it from becoming a generic word.

Personally, I agree with Google. After investing so much time and efforts in building its brand, Google is entitled to its brand name.

Do you agree with me? Or do you think that it is already out of Google’s hands? Please let me know!

Saturday, March 23, 2013

Landmark decision by the US Supreme Court for Resell of Copyrighted Content


In the case of Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley and Sons, the US Supreme Court ruled that American IP owners cannot stop imports and re-selling of copyrighted content that is lawfully sold outside of the US. It marks a major victory for American consumers since it allows them to shop worldwide for content that is covered by IP.

It means that a legal purchaser of a copyright-protected item may dispose of that property anyway he/she sees fit. The court ruled in favor of an immigrant scientist from Thailand., Supap Kirtsaeng,  imported textbooks that were lawfully printed overseas by a U.S. publisher. He then sold those printed textbooks on eBay.

The Supreme Court explained in it ruling that products are nowadays easily bought and sold outside of the US. Customers therefore enjoy a wider choice as well as lower prices for items that companies, libraries, used bookstores and retailers can import to the US, without the need to verify if any there is any US IP for further sale. To quote the Supreme Court: “A geographical interpretation would subject many, if not all, of them to the disruptive impact of the threat of infringement suits.”

This decision preserves the rights that the first-sale doctrine protects manufacturers, retailers, libraries, consumers, and the public at large.

The Supreme Court’s decision could potentially also impact digital content as well as is pharmaceuticals. As a result, people could opt for buying drugs abroad where prices are lower.

The Kirtsaeng case shows us legal eagles that copyright monopoly must be limited to its constitutional purpose. As the Supreme Court stated: “American law … has generally thought that competition, including freedom to resell, can work to the advantage of the consumer”.

Friday, March 15, 2013

Supreme Court to Hear Generic Drug Suit – Could Have Consequences for Pharma Companies Taro and Teva


Generic drugs are supposed to be identical to the brand names that preceded them. According to the law, they must have identical warnings and labels. The question is if they also need to carry the same liability since they cannot change the product or its labeling. The U.S. Supreme Court will rule on that issue soon. .

It will hear oral arguments in a case where consumers claim to be injured by generic drugs. The generic manufacturers in question argue that they should be shielded from those kinds of lawsuits since they do not have any discretion to change the product or its labeling.

A 2011 decision by the court protected generic manufacturers from the most common kind of lawsuit involving prescription drugs. In that case, PLIVA v.Mensing, the court ruled that a generic drug maker could not be held liable for failing to adequately warn consumers of side effects in its labeling, since US federal law requires generic drugs to carry the same label as the brand name.

The current case is Mutual Pharmaceutical Co. v. Bartlett. In this case, the question is if makers of a defective drug — even if they can’t change the label — can stop selling the product without violating federal law and be held accountable if they don’t.

This is one of two Supreme Court cases involving generic drugs. The second one, going before the court soon, centers on what the Federal Trade Commission exactly has labeled as “pay for delay” patent settlements between brand name and generic drugs.

The FDA argues that “pay for delay” is anti-competitive and is costing consumers billions. The generics industry argues that its an efficient way of bringing cheaper products to market before the patents on brand name drugs expire.

The outcome of both cases will impact generic drug manufacturers such as Taro and Teva. 

Friday, February 15, 2013

King Richard III Makes Legal Waves


King Richard III ruled from 1483 until his death on the battlefield of Bosworth Field during the War of the Roses. After his death, King Richard's body was brought to Leicester and buried at Greyfriars Church. The location of both the Greyfriars church and Richard III's grave were eventually lost to history – until recently.

In August 2012, archaeologists of the University ofLeicester began excavating a city council parking lot in Leicester. There were strong indications that the remains of the Greyfriars church could be under it.

The archaeological team unearthed floor tiles, window frames and other remnants of the medieval church, as well as a battle-bruised skeleton. Since it had trauma to the skull and an arrowhead lodged in its spine, there were strong indications that the archaeologists did indeed unearthed the mortal remains of King Richard III. The skeleton also had scoliosis, or an abnormally curved spine, consistent with contemporary accounts of Richard III's appearance

Needless to say, the find caused a stir. Legally speaking, the University of Leicester has jurisdiction over the remains, since it is overseeing the excavation and analysis of all finds.  But various societies, including the U.S.-based Richard III Foundation and the Society of Friends of Richard III based in York, England, argue that the remains should be reburied in York, claim jurisdiction. The Richard III Society has been involved with the archaeological dig in Leicester.  

At this time, the University of Leicester stated that it will officially announce the results of the laboratory analysis of the bones. "If the identity of the remains is confirmed, Leicester Cathedral will continue to work with the Royal Household, and with the Richard III Society, to ensure that his remains are treated with dignity and respect and are reburied with the appropriate rites and ceremonies of the church," the Very Reverend Vivienne Faull, the Dean of Leicester, said in a statement.

Online petition argued that the reburial should take place at Westminster Abbey, Windsor Castle, or in York (the city where he was reportedly building a chapel at the time of his death).

One thing is for sure – even in death, King Richard III created legal waves!